AL Rookie of the Year – 1B Eric Hosmer, Kansas City Royals
Hosmer might not be the man who actually wins this award, but this is probably because his team, the Kansas City Royals, have not been on the national radar for approximately 20 years and did not even sniff the postseason again. The two men he is competing with, starters Ivan Nova and Jeremy Hellickson, both play in the most hyped division in all of baseball and were on postseason teams. The highly touted first basemen did exactly what he was expected to do upon earning his promotion in early May. Rake, rake, and rake some more. Hosmer finished with a .293 average, 19 home runs, and 79 RBIS. Oh yeah, he’s also a burner on the basepaths in regards to first basemen (11 steals). Hosmer’s numbers compare very favorably with the rookie years of other slugging first basemen like Prince Fielder (.271, 28, 81) and Joey Votto (.297, 24, 84). Hosmer looks to be a star in the making. With a lot of other young pieces around him, Hosmer may finally be the player who leads the Royals back to postseason glory.
NL Rookie of the Year – RP Craig Kimbrel, Atlanta Braves
Unlike the American League honors, the National League Rookie of the Year is a no-brainer. Atlanta Braves closer Craig Kimbrel should be the hands down choice over teammate Freddie Freeman and Phillies starter Vance Worley. Kimbrel burst onto the scene with a blazing heater and was entrenched as the Braves’ closer from the beginning of the season. Kimbrel had a sensational campaign compiling a 4-3 record, 2.10 ERA, 1.65 Ks per inning over 77 innings, and converting 46 of 53 save opportunities. While he ultimately cost the Braves a shot at the postseason with his blown save on the last day of the season, it was against the Philadelphia Phillies, the team with the best record in the NL. In fact 4 of his 7 blown saves came against the St. Louis Cardinals, Phillies, and Diamondbacks, all playoff teams. Kimbrel will need to step his game up against the top flight competition, but that will come with experience. The Braves look to be set at closer for the foreseeable future with Kimbrel in place.
AL Manager of the Year – Joe Maddon, Tampa Bay Rays
Early in September the Tampa Bay Rays looked to be dead in the water. On September 1st, they trailed the Boston Red Sox by 9 games for the division and the New York Yankees by 8 games in the Wild Card. Fast forward 4 weeks later and the Rays had a chance to sneak into the playoffs with a Boston loss and a win against the Yankees on the last day of the season. Following a loss by Boston, the Rays, down by 7 runs in the 8th inning, rallied to come back and win in extra innings, propelling them to the postseason in one of the most unlikely postseason bids ever. Tampa earned this honor by grinding the entire season. Evan Longoria missed extended time, B.J. continued his career of erratic play, runs were scarce, but they were able to hold it all together with their exceptional starting pitching. Maddon coaxed a great year from rookie Jeremy Hellickson and great seasons from James Shields, David Price, Jeff Niemann, and Wade Davis. Great defense also played a huge part as Maddon is one of the games leading minds for employing various defensive alignments depending on the batter and situation. The end result should be Maddon winning Manager of the Year honors by continually doing more with less than everyone in baseball.
NL Manager of the Year – Kirk Gibson, Arizona Diamondbacks
If someone were to tell you the Arizona Diamondbacks would make the postseason prior to the 2011 season, you would promptly ask them for the phone number of their drug dealer. The Diamondbacks finished dead last in the NL West in 2010. They were one of the most undisciplined teams at the plate and had a dreadful pitching staff. In just his first full season, manager Kirk Gibson was able to change all of that. Boasting a roster that was largely the same as 2010, their major acquisitions were signing Willie Bloomquist and J.J. Putz, the Diamondbacks climbed from worst to first in the division. Led by career years from outfielder Justin Upton and catcher Miguel Montero, the D-Backs finished 9th in the league in runs scored, very impressive considering they faced the San Francisco Giants’ and San Diego Padres’ pitching staffs for a quarter of the schedule. Gibson showed he was a very capable manager in close games going 28-14 in 1 run affairs. Arizona trailed the defending champion Giants by 4 games at the end of the July, but rolled to win the division by 8 games despite losing starting shortstop Stephen Drew to a broken ankle. Gibson did more than just lead the team to more victories, he instilled a new attitude and demeanor to the ball club. He made them believe they could and would compete with every club out there, and that may be the most important achievement of the season for Gibson going forward.
AL Cy Young – SP Justin Verlander, Detroit Tigers
Justin Verlander’s 2011 season was one of the most impressive seasons we’ve seen in recent years. Verlander was unquestionably the Tigers’ best player all season and willed the Detroit Tigers to the postseason en route to a 24-5 record, 2.40 ERA, .92 WHIP, and 250 strikeouts in 251 innings. The highlight of the year for Verlander came in May against the Toronto Blue Jays. He struck out 4 batters while throwing a no-hitter, the second of his career. With this signature moment combined with his overall statistics, Verlander is a slam dunk pick for the American League Cy Young.
NL Cy Young – SP Clayton Kershaw, Los Angeles Dodgers
The 2011 season was a disappointment for the Los Angeles Dodgers. Despite being in the midst of a ownership struggle between Frank McCourt and MLB Commissioner Bud Selig following an ugly divorce with McCourt’s wife, the team believed it had enough talent to compete for the division. The Dodgers quickly fell out of contention, but not because of Clayton Kershaw’s effort. Kershaw pulled off the pitching crown leading the National League in wins (21), strikeouts (248), and ERA (2.28). Kershaw also threw a career high 5 complete games with 2 shutout efforts. The Dodgers were 23-10 in Kershaw’s starts, but only 59-69 in games started by other pitchers. Add in the fact that Kershaw outdueled 2-time Cy Young winner and World Series Champion Tim Lincecum 4 times over the course of the season, and you have your 2011 Cy Young winner for the National League.
AL MVP – OF Curtis Granderson, New York Yankees
The AL MVP race is most likely the tightest race in all of the postseason awards with 4 candidates all having a chance to win. They are Jacoby Ellsbury, Adrian Gonzalez, Curtis Granderson, and Justin Verlander. All four players had tremendous seasons, but the nod can go to none other than the “Grandy Man” himself. This is not as much as a testament to what he did as an individual as opposed to what the other candidates failed to do. Justin Verlander had a tremendous season, but only pitched one out of every 5 days limiting his impact. Jacoby Ellsbury and Adrian Gonzalez also played very well, but they each played a role in the Red Sox collapse down the stretch that caused them to miss the playoffs. Another factor is that these 2 players will also likely split the votes of those believing a Red Sox player should win the award. That leaves Granderson as the sole survivor, but a very strong one. Despite hitting only .262, Curtis led the league in RBIs with 119 and finished second in the league in home runs with 41. He led the New York Yankees to an AL East crown when a lot of predictions had them missing the playoffs entirely. Granderson finally settled into New York and the Yankee organization to have one of his finest years. He finally became the player the Yankees expected when they traded for him 2 years ago.
NL MVP – OF Ryan Braun, Milwaukee Brewers
Coming into 2011, the abilities of Ryan Braun were overshadowed by Milwaukee Brewers’ teammate Prince Fielder. If you were one of the pitchers who overlooked the “Hebrewer”, you were sure to pay dearly for doing so. Braun finished second in batting average (.332), sixth in home runs (33), fourth in RBIs (111), second in runs (109), and seventh in stolen bases (33). Factor in Braun’s solid defense and the Brewers’ trip to the postseason and that’s one helluva resume. Not bad for a player who was second fiddle on the team. Our apologies to Matt Kemp who had truly sensational numbers, but was on a team who was not playing meaningful baseball for any duration of the season. With Fielder possibly on the way out and Braun coming off his best season, the spotlight will be on him in Milwaukee.